Perspectives of Law and Public Administration
Volume 15, Issue 3, October 2026

Table of Contents

  • Contents


  • 1. Single-Instance Administrative Disputes in Croatia: The Role of the High Administrative Court and the Limits of Judicial Protection

    Associate professor Ana ĐANIĆ ČEKO

    ▼Abstract▼
    With the reform of the administrative dispute implemented in Croatia in 2010, the legislator's intention was to introduce a two-tier system in the organization of the administrative judiciary and to strengthen the role of the High Administrative Court (hereinafter: HAC) as a second-instance court, primarily an appeals court. However, there are exceptions in certain special administrative areas according to special laws, when the resolution of certain administrative matters is excluded from the jurisdiction of first-instance administrative courts and is assigned to a hierarchically higher court. Therefore, legal protection is prescribed through a lawsuit directly to the HAC or, after an appeal against a decision of the first-instance body in administrative procedure, the lawsuit is not filed to the first-instance administrative court but to the HAC. In these disputes, a single-instance administrative dispute is conducted, and in them the HAC has the role of both the first-instance and second-instance court. Therefore, the question arises of the legislator's reasons regarding the justification of granting such exceptions to administrative-judicial protection under special laws. With the new Administrative Disputes Act of 2024, the legislator recognizes the aforementioned issues. The purpose of the paper is to put special emphasis on the specifics of the role and position of the HAC and the justification of exceptions in selected administrative matters, given that a tendency for their increase is observed.
    Keywords: single-instance administrative dispute, High Administrative Court, exceptions, special administrative areas, Administrative Disputes Act 2024.
    JEL Classification: K40, K41, K23

    DOI: 10.62768/PLPA/2026/15/3/01
    HOW TO CITE - Please cite this article as: Đanić Čeko, Ana, „Single-Instance Administrative Disputes in Croatia: The Role of the High Administrative Court and the Limits of Judicial Protection”, Perspectives of Law and Public Administration 15, no. 3 (October 2026): 378-395.


  • 2. Legal Aspects of the Concept of Well-Being in Left-Behind Regions
    Lecturer Andra IFTIMIEI
    ▼Abstract▼
    This research proposes an analysis of the concept of well-being from two perspectives: on the one hand, it aims to identify the normative acts of countries belonging to left-behind regions, in which the concept of well-being is defined; on the other hand, it will also consider jurisprudential aspects derived from court decisions handed down by courts in countries belonging to left-behind regions. Equally, in order to highlight the similarities and differences between the meanings of the concept of well-being, similar provisions in developed countries will also be identified and analyzed. The research hypotheses are as follows: 1. Left-behind regions are not concerned with enshrining the concept of well-being in legislation; 2. There are irreconcilable differences between the concept of well-being in developed countries and the concept of well-being in left-behind regions. The research methods used are literature review, comparative method, and case law analysis. The purpose of the research is to identify whether there is an archetype of the concept of well-being that can be implemented through legal acculturation in left-behind regions.
    Keywords: well-being; left-behind regions; legal regulation; quality of life; public policy.
    JEL Classification: K32

    DOI: 10.62768/PLPA/2026/15/3/02
    HOW TO CITE - Please cite this article as: Iftimiei, Andra, „Legal Aspects of the Concept of Well-Being in Left-Behind Regions”, Perspectives of Law and Public Administration 15, no. 3 (October 2026): 397-412.


  • 3. Between Hard and Soft Law in AI and Healthcare
    Professor Gabriela BELOVA; Associate professor Gergana GEORGIEVA
    ▼Abstract▼
    The present article scrutinises the potential benefits that can be gained from progress in artificial intelligence for revolutionising public health in terms of efficiency, accessibility, and economic sustainability. The primary objective of the study is to examine how artificial intelligence can enhance public health systems while analysing the regulatory challenges associated with its fast development. To achieve these objectives, the study employs a qualitative methodological approach, including a comparative analysis of international soft law instruments, policy documents, and institutional guidelines developed by major global actors such as the UN, UNESCO and others. International soft law in relation to artificial intelligence usually refers to initiatives at the UN, OECD, UNESCO, G20, ISO/IEC, etc. The results of the study indicate that while soft law provides flexibility, adaptability, and rapid responsiveness to technological change, it also suffers from limitations such as a lack of enforceability, accountability gaps, and uneven implementation across jurisdictions. The implications of the study highlight the need for policymakers to integrate soft law principles into formal legal systems, foster international cooperation, and ensure that ethical considerations, transparency, and accountability remain central in the deployment of AI technologies in public health.
    Keywords: international law; health law; cyber law.
    JEL Classification: K33, K32, K24.

    DOI: 10.62768/PLPA/2026/15/3/03
    HOW TO CITE - Please cite this article as: KBelova, Gabriela and Gergana Georgieva, „Between Hard and Soft Law in AI and Healthcare”, Perspectives of Law and Public Administration 15, no. 3 (October 2026): 413-424.


  • 4. Agencification and Fundamental Rights in the EU's Border Management
    PhD Candidate Amira NAMOUCHI
    ▼Abstract▼
    This paper examines the EU’s border management agencies as a manifestation of multi-level governance within the European Union's migration governance system. The paper traces the development of EU agencies within the Area of Freedom, Security and Justice, with particular focus on Frontex from its establishment in 2004 through the landmark reforms of 2016 and 2019. It employs doctrinal analysis to demonstrate how successive crises, including the 2015-migration influx, catalyzed both the operational expansion of Frontex and a heightened emphasis on fundamental rights compliance through the 2019 reform. I further evaluates the accountability and monitoring mechanisms introduced to this end while critically assessing their limitations in terms of transparency and effective oversight. The paper concludes that agencification, while enhancing operational capacity and coordination, simultaneously deepens the complexity of accountability within EU border governance, raising unresolved questions about the balance between institutional autonomy and democratic responsibility.
    Keywords: border management; Frontex; human rights, accountability.
    JEL Classification: K23, K37, K38, H83

    DOI: 10.62768/PLPA/2026/15/3/04
    HOW TO CITE - Please cite this article as: Namouchi, Amira, „Agencification and Fundamental Rights in the EU's Border Management”, Perspectives of Law and Public Administration 15, no. 3 (October 2026): 425-459.


  • 5. Whistleblowing in the South African Legal System: An Analysis of the Protected Disclosures Act, the Legacy of State Capture, and the Path Toward Comprehensive Institutional Reform
    Lecturer Zibele N NODANGALA
    ▼Abstract▼
    The purpose of the study was to offer an exhaustive investigation into the legal, ethical, and sociopolitical dimensions of whistleblowing within the South African context. Centered on the Protected Disclosures Act 26 of 2000 (PDA) and the subsequent Protected Disclosures Amendment Act 5 of 2017, the paper analyzed the systemic failures exposed by the Judicial Commission of Inquiry into Allegations of State Capture (the Zondo Commission). Despite a sophisticated statutory framework, whistleblowers in South Africa face a precarious reality characterized by occupational detriment, financial ruin, and physical violence. The analysis integrates empirical data from Corruption Watch’s 2024 Annual Report to highlight the "accountability chasm" prevalent in the public and private sectors. Using a doctrinal approach to review through desktop a literature of esteemed scholarly work and decided case law, the paper research explored the historical stigma of the "impimpi" and the gendered nature of retaliation, arguing that current protections remain fundamentally labor-centric rather than rights-based. The paper concludes by evaluating proposed reforms, including the establishment of an independent anti-corruption authority and the implementation of a financial incentive (bounty) system through the 2026 "Fallen Whistleblowers Bill," advocating for a holistic shift toward a "social security" model of whistleblower protection.
    Keywords: whistleblowing; Protected Disclosures Act; South Africa; state capture; corruption; occupational detriment; legal reform.
    JEL Classification: K31, K42, D73, H83

    DOI: 10.62768/PLPA/2026/15/3/05
    HOW TO CITE - Please cite this article as: Nodangala, Zibele N. “Whistleblowing in the South African Legal System: An Analysis of the Protected Disclosures Act, the Legacy of State Capture, and the Path Toward Comprehensive Institutional Reform.” Perspectives of Law and Public Administration 15, no. 3 (October 2026): 460-477.


  • 6. Comparative Analysis of AI Governance: The European Union and Emerging Global Trends
    Associate Researcher, PhD Daniela DUȚĂ
    ▼Abstract▼
    The rapid advancement of artificial intelligence technologies has intensified the need for a shared understanding of priority areas in international governance. This paper provides a comparative analysis of AI governance, focusing on the European Union’s regulatory model in relation to emerging global trends. The study examines the extent to which the European Union’s approach, characterized by a risk-based regulatory framework, diverges from or aligns with international initiatives and soft law instruments. Particular attention is devoted to the interaction between binding legal norms and non-binding guidelines, as well as to the role of international cooperation in fostering regulatory convergence. Methodologically, the research employs a comparative legal analysis of key legislative instruments, regulation, and international frameworks related to AI governance. It evaluates normative structures, public consultation processes, and implementation mechanisms across different jurisdictions. The paper further explores the development of safe, secure, and trustworthy AI systems, alongside the protection of human rights, particularly privacy and data protection. It also assesses how principles such as transparency, accountability, and human oversight of AI systems are reflected in international legal standards. The findings indicate an emerging trend toward regulatory convergence, driven by shared ethical principles and the transnational nature of technological challenges. This research contributes by highlighting the legal implications of this convergence and assessing the potential for harmonized international AI governance, emphasizing the role of comparative law in bridging regulatory gaps.
    Keywords: right to privacy, data protection, artificial intelligence, AI Governance.
    JEL Classification: K23, K24, K33, K38

    DOI: 10.62768/PLPA/2026/15/3/06
    HOW TO CITE - Duță, Daniela. “Comparative Analysis of AI Governance: The European Union and Emerging Global Trends.” Perspectives of Law and Public Administration 15, no. 3 (October 2026): 478-492.


  • 7. Rethinking Illegal State Aid in the EU: A Preventive Approach to the Protection of Affected Undertakings
    PhD Candidate Iulian BĂICULESCU
    ▼Abstract▼
    The paper examines the evolution of EU State aid control from a predominantly reactive system towards a more preventive model. The object of study is the concept of unlawful State aid and its implications for the effective protection of undertakings affected by distortive public interventions within the internal market. Moving beyond the traditional understanding of unlawfulness as a procedural breach of Article 108(3) TFEU, the paper advances a broader interpretation, viewing it as an indicator of structural deficiencies within national administrative frameworks responsible for the design and implementation of support measures. Methodologically, the research combines a doctrinal analysis of EU primary and secondary law with an examination of the case law of the Court of Justice of the European Union, complemented by a comparative assessment of national enforcement practices, particularly in sectors such as air transport and energy. The results show that unlawful State aid stems not from isolated infringements, but from recurring administrative shortcomings, including fragmented competences, weak ex ante assessment, and policy priorities over legal compliance. These findings highlight the limits of an ex post system. The paper advocates a preventive model based on stronger ex ante mechanisms and competition-based assessments, with implications for legal certainty and enforcement.
    Keywords: unlawful State aid; affected undertakings; ex ante assessment; national courts; standstill obligation; recovery of State aid.
    JEL Classification: K21, K23, K33

    DOI: 10.62768/PLPA/2026/15/3/07
    HOW TO CITE - Please cite this article as: Băiculescu, Iulian. “Rethinking Illegal State Aid in the EU: A Preventive Approach to the Protection of Affected Undertakings.” Perspectives of Law and Public Administration 15, no. 3 (October 2026): 493-509.


  • 8. Due Process in Albanian Administrative Justice: Reasonable Time and Enforcement of Judgments
    Associate professor Paulina GULI (HOTI
    ▼Abstract▼
    The competencies of general jurisdiction are assigned to courts operating in specific fields, with the aim of delivering higher-quality and more efficient justice, more expeditious justice, as well as ensuring special protection for certain legal relationships. The right of every person to present claims concerning their civil and administrative rights and obligations before an independent and impartial court is exercised through fair, public, and prompt judicial proceedings. Part of this right is also considered the actual execution of the decision given. Delay or postponement in the exercise of this right results in a violation of the rights of its holder. Therefore, the recognition of a right through a judicial decision and its enforcement are intrinsically linked to the legal certainty that must be guaranteed to the individual. The analysis of the activity of the administrative courts to date enables us, on the one hand, to assess the extent to which the purpose of their establishment has been achieved and, on the other hand, to examine the overall state of compliance with human rights requirements for a legal process within reasonable legal time limits. The mission of the courts is not only to administer justice, but also to foster public confidence in the delivery of justice. Extended timeframes for the issuance of administrative judicial decisions, although attributable to objective causes, undeniably affect public trust in the justice system.
    Keywords: legal certainty, adminsitrative court, due process of law, reasonable time limit.
    JEL Classification: K10, K38, K43

    DOI: 10.62768/PLPA/2026/15/3/08
    HOW TO CITE - Please cite this article as: Guli (Hoti), Paulina, „Due Process in Albanian Administrative Justice: Reasonable Time and Enforcement of Judgments”, Perspectives of Law and Public Administration 15, no. 3 (October 2026): 510-521.


  • 9. A Comparative Study of the Vietnam-Hungary Agreement for the Avoidance of Double Taxation and the OECD Model Tax Convention
    PhD Student NGUY Ngoc Anh
    ▼Abstract▼
    In international tax law, double taxation agreements (DTAs) are important instruments to allocate taxing rights between countries and eliminate double taxation on cross-border economic activities. This article conducts a comparative analysis of the 1994 double taxation agreement between Vietnam and Hungary, based on a comparison with the 1963 OECD model convention of the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development. The OECD Model convention is considered an international standard for designing tax agreements. While the Vietnam-Hungary double taxation agreement maintains structural conformity with the OECD model, it also exhibits legal differences to ensure the tax sovereignty of each country. This article will utilize comparative legal analysis and textual analysis to examine the similarities and differences between the OECD Model convention and the Vietnam-Hungary agreement. The results illustrate that although the bilateral agreement adheres to the OECD standard framework, it proactively eliminates property taxes and strengthens the taxing rights of the source country. These differences reflect policy choices aimed at protecting Vietnam's tax base and financial sovereignty. At the same time, the study proposes recommendations to ensure a balance between the trend of international harmonization and the protection of national financial interests in the negotiation of future tax agreements.
    Keywords: Hungary, Vietnam, tax, double taxation, OECD Model, agreement, DTAs.
    JEL Classification: K34, H87, K33

    DOI: 10.62768/PLPA/2026/15/3/09
    HOW TO CITE - Please cite this article as: Ngoc Anh, Nguy, „A Comparative Study of the Vietnam-Hungary Agreement for the Avoidance of Double Taxation and the OECD Model Tax Convention”, Perspectives of Law and Public Administration 15, no. 3 (October 2026): 522-541.


  • 10. The Institutional Logic and Practical Refinement of China’s Data Intellectual Property Registration System
    PhD Candidate Shiya MA
    ▼Abstract▼
    This research analyzes the institutional logic of China’s data intellectual property (IP) registration system to propose a refined legal framework. Employing normative analysis, comparative research, and problem-oriented methods, the study identifies critical bottlenecks in current practices. It reveals that the system’s legitimacy is rooted in the shared intangibility and non-rivalry between data and traditional IP objects. To resolve practical issues such as vague registration objects and unclear legal standing, the paper advocates for defining "data products" as the primary object, adopting the "principle of opposability through publicity" to clarify legal effects, and implementing a composite review mechanism. The analysis distinguishes the evidentiary function of registration from proposals to strengthen its effects on third parties, while clarifying the relationship between national data property registration and local IP initiatives. Recent international literature on proprietary, open and commons-based data governance provides a comparative perspective on how clearer entitlements may support transactions while accommodating lawful access, overlapping rights and the confidentiality of commercially sensitive information. Theoretically, this study enriches the legal doctrine of data rights; practically, it provides legislative references to balance private and public interests, thereby facilitating the orderly circulation of data elements and driving the high-quality development of the digital economy.
    Keywords: data intellectual property registration; institutional logic; data products; data elements; digital economy.
    JEL Classification: K11, K19

    DOI: 10.62768/PLPA/2026/15/3/10
    HOW TO CITE - Please cite this article as: Ma, Shiya, „The Institutional Logic and Practical Refinement of China’s Data Intellectual Property Registration System”, Perspectives of Law and Public Administration 15, no. 3 (October 2026): 542-559.


  • 11. AI, Ethics & the Law: Challenges & Opportunities for a South African Legal Graduate in the Era of Technology
    Postdoctoral Fellow Brian HUNGWE; Senior Lecturer Mpakwana A. MTHEMBU
    ▼Abstract▼
    Artificial Intelligence is progressively getting integrated into the learning and practice of law, often grimly impacting on ethical research and learning for South Africa students. There is an imperative need for a defined responsible AI use in legal education that inculcates a value system in students necessary for future public administration of justice. Often inadvertent dependence on AI outputs provides the urgent need for a regulatory framework that governs AI’s role in both academic research and legal practice. Obsolete academic curriculums that don’t embrace the role and relevance of AI must now adapt to the transformative effect of digital technologies and align their research methodologies towards the same. While the time and automated cost-effective use of AI cannot be contested, the need for clear regulatory parameters that groom students into successful and dependable professionals in the administration of justice is a necessary. This qualitative contribution seeks to highlight areas that should inform a potential regulatory template that avoids the use of algorithms that decide indefensible outcomes. Moreover, judicial decisions are anchored on accurate information to avoid compromising the effective administration of justice. Consequently, a curriculum that doesn’t prepare a student for such an important function fails public administration system.
    Keywords: artificial intelligence; students; law; internet; curriculum.
    JEL Classification: K24, K40, I23

    DOI: 10.62768/PLPA/2026/15/3/11
    HOW TO CITE - Please cite this article as: Hungwe, Brian and Mpakwana A. Mthembu, „AI, Ethics & the Law: Challenges & Opportunities for a South African Legal Graduate in the Era of Technology”, Perspectives of Law and Public Administration 15, no. 3 (October 2026): 560-585.





The Journal

Coperta
ISSN 2601-7830  
ISSN–L 2601-7830 
ETHICS AND MALPRACTICE STATEMENT
POLICY FOR HUMAN-SUBJECTS RESEARCH
Assumption of Liability Declaration

Subscribe to our newsletter

Limba / Language